Newsfeed
Day newsfeed

Government Attacks on Armenian Church Are Unconstitutional

November 16,2026 23:32

Mirror Spectator. Since 2018, the internal political life of the Republic of Armenia has been marked by ever-increasing polarization. Initially, it could have been described as a witch hunt against the former ruling forces but it ultimately appears to be a specific plan of action that seeks global objectives. It is designed to consolidate Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s new, highly personal “ideology”: the Armenian nation is limited to those living within the borders of the Republic of Armenia; the existence of an independent Nagorno-Karabakh represented a threat to Armenia’s territorial integrity; the diaspora is not a component of “real Armenia”; peace with our neighbors requires wiping the slate of past crimes clean.

For the past few months, the political landscape has been shaken by a new attempt to divide society: an all-out attack against the church and its leader. There is long-standing animosity between prime minister and Catholicos of All Armenians Karekin II (dating back to at least 2020), but it has taken an aggressive turn at a time when the government is trying to silence opponents and to find excuses to detain the representatives of political or institutional forces that challenge its policy of capitulation and surrender to an increasingly demanding Azerbaijan. Opponents of this policy are accused of harming national security by representing a threat to the supposedly established “peace” with Azerbaijan, which is clearly still awaiting a final agreement.

It is worth recalling that since August 2018, the government of the Republic of Armenia has been systematically eliminating all constitutional checks and balances. While the ruling party legitimately holds more than two-thirds of the seats in the parliament, there is no longer any democratic debate because no committee chairmanships are reserved for the opposition blocs. All debates or draft resolutions proposed by the opposition in Parliament are either rejected by the Parliament’s Bureau or are doomed to failure if they challenge the prime minister’s program and “vision.”

Outside Parliament, the prime minister has reshaped the judiciary to fit his plan of action. He has dismissed all judges, whether from the judiciary or the Constitutional Court, who do not share his policies or do not comply with his instructions. In short, an independent judiciary no longer exists.

Similarly, he has dismissed all high-ranking officials who serve in legal affairs, intelligence services, national security, the army and the police who oppose him.

This is the context leading up to his attack on the Armenian Apostolic Church, a symbol and pillar of the nation and the preservation of its cultural identity. This institution, beyond its spiritual role, enabled the Armenian nation to survive for six centuries without a state. To weaken the church’s mission, attacks are being launched against priests resisting capitulation and/or abandonment of national values and features on the account of the new ideology.

Constitution and the Church

MORE FROM Armenia & Karabakh

Within this context, let us try to examine the issues driving this conflict dispassionately in light of the Constitution and the law concerning church-state relations, the participation of clergy members in political life, and some ad hominem attacks against the head of the Armenian Church.

The two fundamental provisions of the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia (2015) — a text examined and approved by the Venice Commission, an advisory body of the Council of Europe, before its adoption by referendum — are as follows:

Article 17. The State and Religious Organizations

The freedom of activities of religious organizations shall be guaranteed in the Republic of Armenia.
Religious organizations shall be separate from the State.

Article 18. The Armenian Apostolic Holy Church

The Republic of Armenia shall recognize the exclusive mission of the Armenian Apostolic Holy Church, as a national church, in the spiritual life of the Armenian people, in the development of their national culture and preservation of their national identity.
The relations between the Republic of Armenia and the Armenian Apostolic Holy Church may be regulated by law.

The first article enshrines the separation of church and state and the church’s freedom of activity. It guarantees, in particular, the church’s autonomy in matters of doctrine, governance, and the election of its supreme head, the Catholicos of All Armenians. The second article implicitly recognizes the Armenian Church’s special mission to the entire nation, both in Armenia and in the diaspora.

The law regulating the relations between the church and the Republic of Armenia (paradoxically predating the 1995 Constitution, amended in 2005 and 2015) has been adopted by the Supreme Council in 1991. That is the “Law on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations of the Republic of Armenia.” Several bills have been proposed to amend or replace it, particularly between 2009 and 2017. The last bill received joint opinions from the Venice Commission of the Council of Europe and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, but it will never be put to a vote in the National Assembly.

The applicable law therefore remains that of 1991. As to relations between Religious Organizations and the State, it specifies:

Section 17

In the Republic of Armenia, Church and State are separate. On the basis of this separation the State:

  1. a) Shall not force a citizen to adhere to any religion.
    b) Shall not interfere in the activities and internal affairs of church and Religious Organizations as long as they operate in accordance with the law, no state agency or person acting on behalf of such agency shall operate within a Religious Organization.
    c) Prohibits the participation of the Church in governing the State and shall not impose any governmental functions on the Church or Religious Organization.

The State shall not obstruct the efforts of the Armenian Church in pursuing the following activities which we expressly reserved to be her privilege solely:

(…)

At the same time, the Armenian Apostolic Church as the national Church of Armenians, which also operates outside the Republic, shall enjoy the protection of the Republic of Armenia, within the framework of international legal norms.

Section 18

The State shall finance neither the activity of Religious Organizations nor of atheistic propaganda. At the same time, the state guarantees the right of the members or employees of Religious Organizations to take part in the civil and political life on an equal basis with other citizens.

Absent an opinion of the Constitutional Court, Armenia’s Public Council held a consultation on June 12, 2025, and declared that “ (…) emphasizing the importance of preserving public solidarity, mutual respect, and tolerance, it sees the resolution of the current situation exclusively within the legal framework, guided by the Constitution of the Republic of Armenia, the Law on Relations Between the Republic of Armenia and the Armenian Apostolic Holy Church, and the Law on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations.” “Accordingly, the Church and clergy must maintain political neutrality, and the state, in turn, must refrain from interfering in the Church’s internal procedures.”

However, the law on “Relations between the Republic of Armenia and the Armenian Apostolic Church” (Law of 2007) does not elaborate on political neutrality. It just stipulates in its Article IV that the “guiding principles” of the relationship between those two institutions are governed by the Constitution, while their “general relations” are governed by the Law on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations (Law of 1991), as well as by other laws and international agreements. The Venice Commission of the Council of Europe has recognized the 2007 law as a special law.

Absent the independence of the Public Council, its interpretation is then null and void. Unfortunately, the Constitutional Court, if it were to be consulted, would not be independent, either.

Therefore, any attempt to subject the Church to state control or any state interference in the internal affairs of the Church violates the constitutional guarantees of the Republic of Armenia (Articles 17 and 18 of the Constitution and of the Law on Freedom of Conscience and Religious Organizations).

It also violates the European Convention. In a landmark case, Holy Synod of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church (Metropolitan Inokentiy) and others v. Bulgaria (2009), the Court held that the State, by intervening to determine which group of believers and clergy should be considered the legal representative of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church, had breached its duty of neutrality and impartiality. By recognizing one leader and rejecting the other, the State had arbitrarily interfered in the internal affairs of the Church, thereby violating the religious group’s autonomy to choose its own leaders. The Court found a violation of Article 9 (Freedom of thought, conscience and religion) of the Convention. The case was concerning a schismatic crisis within the Bulgarian Orthodox Church. The Bulgarian state authorities had recognized and supported the faction led by Patriarch Maxim, to the detriment of the other faction led by Metropolitan Inokentiy (the applicant). In particular, the government had legalized the statutes of Patriarch Maxim’s faction and refused to recognize Metropolitan Inokentiy’s leadership.

The Constitution also provides for the participation of members of the clergy in political life, on an equal footing with any other citizen, all within the bounds of the law.

Philippe Raffi Kalfayan

Read more at the source

Media can quote materials of Aravot.am with hyperlink to the certain material quoted. The hyperlink should be placed on the first passage of the text.

Comments (0)

Leave a Reply